The Tempinis diaries

January 3, 2008

AP Interview: Malaysia’s Indian protest movement likely to die soon, says leader

Filed under: malaysia — Tags: , , — toru @ 3:34 pm
This interview with the Hindraf leader caught my eye.  If Waytha Moorthy knows that the protest movement will likely die soon – why make such a broad ranging demands in the first place?  While I am sympathetic to the fact that Malaysian Indians are marginalised in Malaysia, I mean most of their 18 points demands are quite unrealistic.   RM 100 billion funding for Tamil schools?  I don’t even think the Malaysian government spends that much on universities in Malaysia!  Reserve 20 % of top government posts for Indians?  Common – that will never happen in today’s political climate.  Of course the Malaysian government is not conceding at all.
These Hindraf guys are very brave but politically naive.  The sad part of all this is that besides the international spotlight, I dont think anything has been achieved for the Malaysian Indian community.  It would have been better if they had been more modest in their demands e.g. government funding for let’s say 5 Tamil schools in every Malaysian state.  At least that’s something concrete that will help the Malaysian Indians.  By making such wide demands, they actually got nothing.
Wednesday, January 2, 2008
LONDON: Minority ethnic Indians are fighting a “losing battle” for equal rights in Malaysia, and their fledgling protest movement against the Muslim-dominated government is likely to die soon, a protest leader told The Associated Press. Ultimately, only the government — not the people — can bring about real change by giving concessions to ethnic Indians, said P. Waytha Moorthy, the chairman of the Hindu Rights Action Force group, or Hindraf, that is leading the Indian movement.”We are fighting a losing battle, we know. We try our level best but if we don’t succeed, we have to call it a day, isn’t it?” Moorthy said in the interview this week in the London suburb of Hounslow, where he is living with friends in self-imposed exile.

“We have to close the chapter. There may be a new chapter, but we may not be part of the next chapter,” a tired-looking Moorthy said during the chat at a McDonald’s restaurant. “I know, eventually we will also fail.”

Ethnic Indians form about 8 percent of Malaysia’s 27 million people, and complain that the government denies them opportunities in jobs, education and business. They say that years of systematic repression have kept them at the bottom of society. The government denies this and says all Malaysians have benefited from the spectacular progress of the export-driven economy since independence in 1957.

“We want the minority Indians to be given their basic rights If they can give us two or three (real concessions), we are willing to keep our mouth shut,” Moorthy said.

“That’s what I don’t understand: why isn’t the government conceding? We are not asking for super rights, we are asking for basic rights.”

Ethnic Indians, most of them descendants of 19th century plantation workers from southern India, also accuse the government of turning a blind eye to the destruction by local civic authorities of Hindu temples.

Moorthy’s statements are the most honest and frank assessment of the reality faced by the minority community who have little economic or political clout. Malaysia’s majority Malay Muslims, who are 60 percent of the population, control the government, while the ethnic Chinese — who are a quarter of the population — dominate business.

The Indian frustrations took public shape for the first time when Hindraf organized a massive rally on Nov. 25 of about 30,000 people in defiance of a government ban.

Moorthy fled the country fearing arrest but five other Hindraf leaders were subsequently detained under the Internal Security Act, which allows indefinite jail without trial. They were accused of being a threat to national security but no charges have been filed.

Moorthy said public support for Hindraf has increased after the arrests, but the movement was “stagnant” now.

“What we can, we will still do. But if the whole struggle is going to die, what can we do?” he said. “As it stands now I don’t think we can accelerate.”

He said he doesn’t regret starting the movement.

“I will never regret but I feel sorry” for those detained and “frustrated with the system, the government.”

He said his biggest worry is that when Hindraf fails, the poor and uneducated Indians will come to hate the government even more, and may resort to violence. He added he does not condone or support violence in any form.

He said he plans to stay in London for now and continue lobbying internationally.

“I would prefer to keep pushing, keep the people’s spirit high. The safest thing to do is to conduct prayers.”


Leave a Comment »

No comments yet.

RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URI

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

Create a free website or blog at

%d bloggers like this: